Can I Subscribe the Same Audience to a New Newsletter?

If you’re launching a new newsletter and already have an audience, here’s what the law allows — and what we recommend.

What U.S. law allows (CAN-SPAM)

Under the CAN-SPAM Act there is no affirmative opt-in requirement for commercial email in the United States. You may email existing subscribers about a new newsletter as long as:

The email accurately identifies you as the sender.
It includes your valid physical mailing address.
It includes a clear, easy way to unsubscribe.
You honor unsubscribe requests within 10 business days.

Subscribers always retain the right to opt out, and some U.S. states have additional email solicitation rules — confirm your approach aligns with any applicable state-level regulations.

If a recipient is in the European Union or UK, consent is required before subscribing them to a new newsletter. Automatically adding them without consent is not GDPR-compliant.

Recommended best practice

Even when legally permitted, auto-subscribing people to a new newsletter can hurt engagement and deliverability.

Promote the new publication inside your existing newsletter with an in-house ad, banner, or callout so readers voluntarily subscribe. This typically brings higher engagement, fewer spam complaints, and better long-term deliverability.

Option 2: Send it with clear disclosure

If you do send the new newsletter to your existing audience:

Explain why recipients are receiving it (they subscribed to your existing newsletter).
Make clear what the new newsletter is about.
Include a clear and easy way to unsubscribe from it.

Summary

CAN-SPAM allows commercial email without prior opt-in, provided unsubscribe rules are followed.
Subscribers always have the right to opt out.
EU/UK subscribers require explicit consent.
Best practice is to invite subscribers to opt in rather than adding them automatically — when unsure, opting in is the safest path.

Still can’t find what you need? Contact support.